Standing on the stage receiving the Dr. Stanley Pearle Award with his wife Stacy Mazzarella in late 2023 was a full-circle moment for Carmine Mazzarella. More than 30 years earlier, the young optician—barely out of his teens—met Dr. Pearle at a training seminar. “I didn’t have the money or the experience to take on a Pearle location, but he encouraged me and mentored me. He saw something in me, so receiving the award with his name on it was a tremendous honor,” he says.
Stacy and Carmine Mazzarella accept the Dr. Stanley Pearle Award
Young Carmine Mazzarella (left) found a years-long mentor with Dr. Stanley Pearle (right).
Carmine Mazzarella has been nominated multiple times for the Dr. Stanley Pearle Award, but as some of the criteria are weighted heavily on year-over-year growth, it can be more difficult for an established 30-year-old location to nail those metrics.
Recently, however, the growth of their second location, acquired in 2020, was robust enough to push them to the top. The second practice, in Burlington, Massachusetts, is about 30 miles away from the original one in Saugus. For this acquisition, the Mazzarellas leaned into the Ignite program from Pearle, which provides some incentives to help eye care professionals convert former private practices to the Pearle brand.
The practice they acquired was not a Pearle location, but the doctor was retiring. She had earned her MD in China but was working as an OD in the U.S. Even so, the practice was highly medical, with exam slots of one hour, followed by the doctor being involved in the frame styling.
“There are challenges to taking over a private practice and moving it to the Pearle brand,” says Carmine Mazzarella. “Sometimes patients prefer going to a private practice because they have misperceptions about a corporate-affiliated location.” And some staff, who may have worked in a corporate location in the past, aren’t interested in doing so again, he says.
Rebuilding and re-educating
In this case, one of the two staff members associated with the old practice had already decided she was ready to retire as well. He recalls that it took a little effort to get the one remaining staff person to buy in. It wasn’t that she was unwilling to change, but she was skeptical that the new model could bring the two- or even three-times growth that he told her he expected. “There was nothing inherently wrong with her system of management, but it wasn’t scalable to accommodate the growth I felt would come,” he says.
As the patient volume grew, that employee—who was working on her master’s degree in another field—could see the wisdom of the plans he implemented. When she left to pursue her career, the last connection to the old practice was gone.
He also knew he would have to re-educate some patients about what they could expect in the location under this new management. That meant he would inevitably lose some patients who insisted on getting their medical eye care with long appointment times. But those who stayed were happy with the changes: a larger and more contemporary frame selection and greater efficiency.
In fact, the day they relaunched as a Pearle location, they were able to tap into the online appointment scheduler through Pearle. “As soon as we flipped the switch, people were booking within minutes. That’s the power of the brand, and it’s part of the reason I’ve stayed with Pearle.”
Gambling on a new location
Around the same time, the Mazzarellas began negotiating for a third business, a relatively new Pearle location. Unfortunately, that doctor’s health declined very quickly, so the couple was able to acquire only the records and equipment, but not the location itself. Even so, they put the equipment and furniture into storage and were able to use it with the new practice. It also meant that the region had lost one Pearle location, which made him even more sure he’d have the patient base for the new endeavor.
The location they did acquire was in a high-end mall, and they shopped around for a larger space inside the mall. But the rent was too high. They even looked at a space that was inside the mall parking lot, but the rent there was three times higher than what they were able to find 1,000 yards away. “It’s not as visible as it would have been in the mall, but I was willing to bet that people would find us. And they did.”
Through the Ignite program, converted Pearle locations have up to five years before they need to remodel to incorporate the full Pearle look. Since the Mazzarellas were moving the location and they had everything from the dismantled Pearle location, they decided to do the full branding remodel right at the start. “It slowed us down in opening a little bit, but now, three years into owning this, I’m not looking at a remodel. We did that already before we had a patient base,” he says.
Carmine Mazzarella says that the Ignite program mitigates some of the risks for converting a location to Pearle. “I knew the market. I knew it was a strong market for Pearle,” he says. He is the optician; Stacy Mazzarella is the manager, working with staff and managing billing and orders.
The Mazzarellas and their team
|